Identifying the Best Science Fiction Short Stories Ever Written

by James Wallace Harris, Thursday, August 2, 2018

Adventures in Time and Space edited by Healy and McComasMy friends Mike, Piet, and I are making a list of the most remembered science fiction short stories. The problem is how to create a great list. We don’t want to list our personal favorites. Instead, we’re studying all the ways SF short stories are remembered by readers, critics, editors, and writers. We’re collecting lists of recommended stories into a database and intend to make the most frequently remembered stories into our Classics of Science Fiction Short Stories list. This is a time-consuming project, and I’m using this blog to think about how we’re doing it. I’m open to suggestions and recommendations.

Most bookworms prefer novels. Anthologies and author story collections sell poorly. Science fiction magazines have damn few subscribers nowadays but there are or will be at least 11 best-of-the-year anthologies collecting short works of science fiction this year. That suggests a healthy interest in the shorter forms of science fiction. (And yesterday I read “The Rise of the Sci-Fi Novella: All the Imagination, None of the Burden” by Jason Kehe.) We want to help SF fans find the older stories that are becoming forgotten that evolved the genre.

We’re hoping short science fiction is making a comeback. I’ve always considered the science fiction magazine, first the pulps, then the digests, and now the online magazines, to be the heart of science fiction. Short science fiction focuses on the science fictional idea, and that’s what I love best about the genre. Of course, this runs counter to the prevailing winds of long novels, trilogies, and endless series.

In 2018 I’ve been reading lots of short science fiction. I’ve read best-of-the-year annuals covering 1939, 1940, 1941, 1942, 1943, 2016, 2017. Plus an anthology of the best SF stories of the 1950s. I’ve also been randomly jumping around through the years from the 19th to the 21st centuries. I’m slowly developing a sense of how science fiction developed over time.

At first, I was just going to make a list of my favorite stories for my own use. Then I started an online reading club, The Great SF Stories v. 1-25 (1939-1963) to discuss the stories in the Isaac Asimov and Martin H. Greenberg series with others. I also joined the Classic Science Fiction & Fantasy Short Story club. I’ve found a handful of dedicated fans of short science fiction. Recently, Piet Nel and I decided to create a Classics of Science Fiction Short Stories list for my site  Classics of Science Fiction. My friend Mike, a programming wizard, volunteered to churn through our data.

The internet provides countless lists of best SF novels, but damn few for short stories. We’ve been studying those lists and how they were made. One side-effect of being a list maker is learning about how we remember the past. For fiction, either novels or short stories, it’s the tales that stay with us that we put on personal lists. That doesn’t necessarily mean they were the best stories, deserving to be remembered, or even well-written stories. It means they were great at triggering your emotions. One day I hope to feel confident enough to make my own list of stories I believe others should take the time to read. For now, I’m seeking the wisdom of crowds.

Fan Polls

Fan polls are a good method for identifying stories that we collectively remember. Of course, as individuals, we often fondly recall stories that meant something to us but not to others. So the truest best list of stories is the one you make for yourself. However, a list of stories that many others love is a great tool for finding fiction you might love too.

Here are the fan polls we’re working with:

Peter Sykes at Sci-Fi Lists used anthologies and other sources to create a ballot. Visitors to his site vote for stories and can nominate new ones. He updates the results yearly. I like his results because many of the stories on his list are ones I remember. When I read through his list I feel like I’m fairly well acquainted with science fiction history.

Locus also allows their readers to nominate stories, and it tends to get newer stories onto its lists quicker. Often, I’m less familiar with those stories.

The ISFDB list is interesting because it’s based on the number of hits stories get when people are researching the ISFDB database. This doesn’t mean they are its favorite stories, but they are stories people are remembering for some reason.

If you know of any other fan polls for short SF let me know.


Awards are a key indicator of successful stories, but not a perfect one. Some awards, like the Hugo and Locus, are selected by fans. Others, like the Nebula, are chosen by professional writers. Still, other awards are determined by panels of experts. Each has their track record for spotting lasting stories. Awards are given the year after publication. During that second year, we also see annual best-of-the-year anthologies pick their favorite stories from the previous year. Sometimes awards and anthologies overlap in their selections, sometimes not.

Best of the Year Anthologies

Best_science_fiction_stories_1949We’ve also entered into our database all the anthologies that collect the best science fiction stories of the year. These annuals began in 1949 with the Bleiler & Dikty Best Science Fiction Stories series. However, Asimov & Greenberg in 1979 jumped back to 1939 and produced The Great SF Stories series, which ran until 1964. There have been at least one, if not several, annual anthologies ever since that collect the best stories. Just as the Bleiler/Dikty series was petering out in the mid-1950s, Judith Merril took the helm of a new series. Then Donald Wollheim and Terry Carr were the caretakers of their annual best-of-the-year anthologies. Quite a few others tried developing an annual anthology but they were short-lived. It took two tries, but eventually, Gardner Dozois produce the longest running anthology series to date finishing the 35th volume before he died. Around the turn of the century David Hartwell, and then Jonathan Strahan put out collections of the annual best short science fiction, to be eventually joined by Rich Horton, Allan Kaster, and Neil Clarke. There are many others working the same territory.

These editors really know short stories. They are the experts. They often champion stories that fans don’t. Their input gives our list more authority.

Retrospective Anthologies

After that all-important second year after publication, stories languish until they reappear in an author’s short story collection, or anthologized in theme and retrospective anthologies. For our purpose, we’ve tracked down all the great retrospective anthologies that worked to showcase a historical sweep of the genre. Often these anthologies are created by established writers, which give their picks another kind of recognition and authority.

Textbook Anthologies

Science fiction is now taught in college courses. Schools provide another kind of authority for recognizing classics. These are usually big expensive books, but they do come with great introductions that put the stories into context. Scholars provide a different kind of insight regarding the memory of SF stories, seeing important societal themes revealed in them.

Coming Soon – The Classics of Science Fiction Short Stories

We’re still working on our project, but I thought I’d write about what we’re doing in hopes readers might have other ideas of how to spot old science fiction short stories that are still readable today and make an impact. Sadly, science fiction dates rather quickly. It’s quite easy to look back over the history of science fiction and see many eras of distinctive science fictional movements that are no longer read.

There are some fans that will read old science fiction even if its ideas are obviously scientifically wrong. But for any story to work for new readers, it must stand on its own. Its success at storytelling must succeed with today’s twelve-year-olds as well as life-long genre fans. Just read the story reports at Young People Read Old SFF for brutal honesty and insight of today’s kids.

Sometimes a story becomes a classic because society changes. A great example is the 1909 story, “The Machine Stops” by E. M. Forster. Without the internet, this story has much less impact. I’m sure readers in 1909 thought Forster was crazy but 21st-century readers will think he’s Nostradamus.

The Big Book of Science Fiction edited by Jeff and Ann VanderMeerEvery new generation needs editors who will search out the old stories that will speak to the latest generation coming of age. Jeff and Ann VanderMeer’s 2016 anthology The Big Book of Science Fiction does just that.

I’m sure there are many other ways to identify classic short stories. Some short stories have become movies, like Heinlein’s “All You Zombies …” or “Story of Your Life” by Ted Chiang, or the many stories by Philip K. Dick that have been dramatized. Being filmed would be another good indicator of a classic story, but I don’t know how to make a list of them. It’s surprising how many SF short stories have been made into forgettable films, such as The Twonky.

Sadly, readers don’t remember short stories as well as novels. Can you name 12 classic literary short stories? Or, 12 classic mystery or western short stories? Recently I got my book club to pick an anthology of science fiction to read. I tried hard to get them interested, reviewing a story a day. But no one took the bait. My fellow book club members claimed short stories didn’t hold their interest, and they wanted novels that could keep them entertained for hours or days.

This is a shame. I believe science fiction short stories are superior to novels for delivering science fictional ideas. Novels are great for characterization and plots, but they feel too padded if you’re reading to be wowed by a far-out concept. When I was growing up, most paperback SF novels were less than 200 pages, often around 160. The Ace Double was very popular, and they contained two novellas. A 132-page science fiction magazine would include a serialized novel segment or novella, two novelettes and a handful of short stories. A good issue could leave you thinking about 10-12 mindbending ideas.

In 2018 I’ve switched from mainly reading science fiction novels to science fiction short stories and it’s been far more fulfilling. Just in the past two days, I’ve reread “Bloodchild” by Octavia E. Butler, “Day Million” by Frederik Pohl and “When It Changed” by Joanna Russ. They dealt with a horrifying symbiotic relationship with an alien species, a transhuman/transgender love story, and a society of women who’ve lived without men for hundreds of years having to deal with them again.

Let me know what you think about short stories. Let me know what you think about reading long lists of story titles. We’re also working on ways to improve how a list is presented. Let me know if you know of any great list of SF short stories.


27 thoughts on “Identifying the Best Science Fiction Short Stories Ever Written”

  1. The “best remembered” stories is a very good way of putting it. That’s all you can really claim. I agree that the list shouldn’t just be our own favorite stories, but nevertheless, when we have our final results, I may make a separate list of my own favorites, just because the comparison will be fun. And illuminating.

    1. I’m going to work on my personal list too, but it’s going to take a long time. I want to read all the stories on our list when we finalize it before deciding my favorites. I’d like to also have read all the annual anthologies, but I’m not sure when I’ll be finished.

  2. I am in awe of the Project you , Piet, and Mike have embarked on! From what you’ve laid out, you’re going about choosing the stories in a solid, methodical fashion. I’m sure the final list of stories will be eagerly appraised on sites like BLACK GATE and LOCUS.

  3. I’ve long believed that a short story or novella is the best forum for idea-driven science fiction. Novels are perhaps better for world-building. Catherine L. Moore’s “Shambleau” and “No Woman Born” or Ray Bradbury’s “The Sound of Thunder” would be nowhere near as effective if they were drawn out to 200 or more pages. While I guess there is no clear way to define them, but really short short stories (around a page long) can sometimes be more memorable than some novels. I’m thinking here of Arthur C. Clarke’s “Reunion” and Frederic Brown’s “Answer”.

    Good luck on this project! I look forward to seeing the results.

    1. I saw that article yesterday. When building the Classics of Science Fiction list the data showed there were books fans loved and books that critics loved. Because there are few polls asking readers about their favorite short stories, fan input is rather slight for our study. For short stories, it’s anthologists that generally remember them.

      We need more sites doing “The Great American Read” type surveys for short stories. There is great stock put in being well-read regarding novels, but society puts little stock in short stories.

      As the WSJ article points out, readers are remembering the stories they read for fun, and not what critics considered great. That seems to imply most people don’t find short stories fun.

  4. It would add further complexity to your project, but I wonder if thematic groupings (and a story could be in more than one) would be helpful. Possible thematic groupings: time travel, aliens, war, post-apocalypse, technological extrapolation, mad scientist, mutants.

    1. An added benefit of the thematic grouping is that you could use the various sf encyclopedias’ theme entries to get further title possibilities.

      I like the idea of personal lists. I suspect all readers of sf short stories have stories they remember that no one else does. Why they remember them is idiosyncratic: first encounter with a particular idea, circumstances of character and setting, and setting.

      1. Marzaat, I think people also respond to short stories because of a style/mood of writing. Ray Bradbury type stories appeal to some people, while Philip K. Dick type of story appeals to others. I’ve always like Robert F. Young’s stories, but he is seldom remembered today. When I reread “Bloodchild” by Octavia E. Butler the other day, it reminded me of certain stories by Philip Jose Farmer. So I’m not talking about a specific writing style, but creating a kind of mood or voice. I guess we could call these moods micro-genres. For example, “Jeffty is Five” by Harlan Ellison creates a certain mood, that is similar to “Travels With My Cats” by Mike Resnick.

        1. Yes, mood is an important consideration. (I don’t read on that basis, but a lot of people do.) If only some clever linguist programmer could quantify what mood is (word choice, sentence length and how variable it is, preponderance of certain words), we could have a AI sf version of Pandora. Feed in your favorite titles and get more like it!

    2. I’ve wanted to build an SF theme database for a long time. I like what Michael Main has done for time travel at his site

      I’d love to write essays that follow the evolution of specific science fiction themes over time. Brian Ash’s The Visual Encyclopedia of Science Fiction did that for many themes, but it’s forty years out of date.

  5. You have taken on a worthy project. “Most bookworms prefer novels. Anthologies and author story collections sell poorly. Science fiction magazines have damn few subscribers …” I think this is true of short stories in all genres. Novels offer long-term escape and continuity. Short story collections offer rapid fire ideas, scene and character changes, new challenges. This may be more than a modern, changing-world reader can take.

  6. I’m really looking forward to seeing how this turns out. I’ve been reading Jo Walton’s new book on the history of the Hugos. For each year of the awards, there are comments from Gardner Dozois and Rich Horton on the short story selections, and their own takes on the best stories of each year. I’d suggest taking a look, as it’s pretty clear they have the breadth of reading for informed opinions, and they could be seen as another indicator of what stories are being remembered…

  7. Thanks for a thoughtful discussion and article.
    Y’know, because of you I just finished spending several hundred dollars buying old sci-fi paperbacks.! Your blog gave me permission to free my imprisoned love of sic-covers. NOW I’m getting the sci-fi short story fever and will be buying “The Big Book of Science Fiction”. Mainly the cover, but I will be reading. I’m 63, and starting to decided where I want my time to go, so MORE SHORT STORIES – yessssssssssss!

  8. Sorry, I meant Sci-Fi, not sic, and decide, not decided.
    (Why did I type that at 10:50 AM EST and it’s showing as 2:59 PM?)

  9. Great post! I also liked “Science Fiction Stories Beyond Normal”. That book has a few original ideas that really make you think. H. G. Wells is another great source of concepts to think about.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Where one line can make a difference.

Engaging With Aging

As long as we're green, we're growing

A Deep Look by Dave Hook

Thoughts, ramblings and ruminations


A story a day keeps the boredom away: SF and Fantasy story reviews


Pluralism and Individuation in a World of Becoming

the sinister science

sf & critical theory join forces to destroy the present

Short Story Magic Tricks

breaking down why great fiction is great

Xeno Swarm

Multiple Estrangements in Philosophy and Science Fiction

fiction review

(mostly) short reviews of (mostly) short fiction

A Just Recompense

I'm Writing and I Can't Shut Up

Universes of the Mind

A celebration of stories that, while they may have been invented, are still true

Iconic Photos

Famous, Infamous and Iconic Photos

Make Lists, Not War

The Meta-Lists Website

From Earth to the Stars

The Asimov's Science Fiction Magazine Author & Editor Blog

SFF Reviews

Short Reviews of Short SFF

Featured Futures

classic science fiction and more

Sable Aradia, Priestess & Witch

Witchcraft, Magick, Paganism & Metaphysical Matters

Pulp and old Magazines

Pulp and old Magazines

Matthew Wright

Science, writing, reason and stuff

My Colourful Life

Because Life is Colourful

The Astounding Analog Companion

The official Analog Science Fiction and Fact blog.

What's Nonfiction?

Where is your nonfiction section please.

A Commonplace for the Uncommon

Books I want to remember - and why

a rambling collective

Short Fiction by Nicola Humphreys

The Real SciBlog

Articles about riveting topics in science

West Hunter

Omnes vulnerant, ultima necat

The Subway Test

Joe Pitkin's stories, queries, and quibbles regarding the human, the inhuman, the humanesque.

SuchFriends Blog

'...and say my glory was I had such friends.' --- WB Yeats

Neither Kings nor Americans

Reading the American tradition from an anarchist perspective


Speculations on the Future: Science, Technology and Society

I can't believe it!

Problems of today, Ideas for tomorrow


Peter Webscott's travel and photography blog

The Wonderful World of Cinema

Where classic films are very much alive! It's Wonderful!

The Case for Global Film

'in the picture': Films from everywhere and every era

A Sky of Books and Movies

Books & movies, art and thoughts.

Emily Munro

Spinning Tales in the Big Apple


hold a mirror up to life.....are there layers you can see?

%d bloggers like this: